10 Common A/B Testing Mistakes to Avoid in 2024

A/B testing helps businesses boost online performance, but many companies make costly errors. Here are 10 common A/B testing mistakes to avoid this year:

1. Not setting clear goals
2. Overlooking statistical significance
3. Testing too many things at once
4. Ending tests too early
5. Forgetting about mobile users
6. Not grouping users correctly
7. Ignoring seasonal changes
8. Reading results incorrectly
9. Not repeating tests
10. Skipping user feedback

Quick Comparison:

Mistake	Impact	How to Avoid
No clear goals	Wasted effort, poor results	Set specific objectives and metrics
Ignoring statistics	False positives/negatives	Use proper sample sizes, aim for 95% confidence
Over-testing	Unclear results	Test one major change at a time
Rushing tests	Inaccurate data	Run tests for at least 2-4 weeks
Mobile oversight	Missed opportunities	Test separately for mobile and desktop
Poor segmentation	Misleading insights	Group users by relevant criteria
Seasonal blindness	Skewed results	Account for time-based behavior changes
Misreading data	Bad decisions	Look beyond averages, consider all metrics
One-and-done	Outdated insights	Retest regularly, especially after changes
Ignoring feedback	Missed context	Combine quantitative and qualitative data

By avoiding these mistakes, you'll run better tests, get more accurate results, and make smarter choices for your digital strategy in 2024.

Related video from YouTube

1. Not Setting Clear Goals

Many companies dive into A/B testing without a plan. Bad idea. You need clear goals to make A/B testing work.

Why? Clear goals:

• Focus your efforts
• Help measure success
• Align tests with business goals

Here's how to set clear A/B testing goals:

1. Pick your main business goal

Ask yourself: "What's our end game?" An e-commerce site might want more sales. A SaaS company? More sign-ups.

2. Choose the right metrics

Pick metrics that match your goal. For example:

Goal	Metrics to Track
More sales	Conversion rate, Average order value
More sign-ups	Sign-up rate, Time to sign up

3. Create a specific hypothesis

Use an if-then statement. Like this:

"If we make the 'Add to Cart' button bigger, then more people will buy."

This approach helps you solve real user problems. As FigPii's blog puts it:

"Setting and tracking specific goals gives you a clear direction and lets you measure your test's success."

Base your hypothesis on data. If Google Analytics shows 95% of customers bail before paying, aim to cut that number down.

2. Overlooking Statistical Significance

Many A/B testers make a big mistake: they ignore statistical significance. This can lead to wrong decisions based on chance results.

Statistical significance is like a trust score for your data. It tells you if your test results are real or just luck.

Why does it matter? It helps you:

• Avoid false positives
• Ensure reliable results
• Prevent wasting time on useless changes

How to check for statistical significance:

1. Set a confidence level (usually 95%)

2. Use a calculator

Many tools can help. VWO's Statistical Significance Calculator does the math for you. Just input your visitor and conversion numbers.

3. Look at the p-value

A p-value below 0.05? Your results are statistically significant at 95% confidence.

Real-world example:

Testing two button colors:

Version	Visitors	Conversions
Blue	10,000	500
Red	10,000	550

Red looks better, right? Not so fast.

Using a calculator, you might find a p-value of 0.12. That's above 0.05, meaning the difference isn't statistically significant. You can't be sure red is actually better.

Key takeaway: Always check for statistical significance before making changes based on A/B test results.

"Statistical significance is a complex concept that is often misused in the world of A/B testing." - Uwemedimo Usa, Conversion Copywriter

Reaching statistical significance takes time. Be patient. IDX reports their tests reach significance over 66% of the time, with an average conversion rate increase of 22%.

Don't rush. Let tests run for at least a week, but no more than 8 weeks. This ensures your data is both significant and current.

3. Testing Too Many Things at Once

A/B testing is about finding what works. But test too much, and you'll muddy the waters.

Here's the issue: Change multiple elements and see a conversion boost? You won't know what made the difference.

Let's break it down:

A/B vs. Multivariate Testing

Test Type	Variables	Complexity	Traffic Needed
A/B Test	1-2	Low	Less
Multivariate	3+	High	More

A/B tests? Simple and fast. Great for big changes or less traffic.

Multivariate tests? Can test many elements. But need lots of traffic and time.

The Traffic Trap

Picture this: You're running a test with 12 page versions. Your page gets 1,000 views a week. Each version? Only about 83 views. Not enough for solid results.

How to Avoid This Mistake

1. Keep it simple. Test one big change at a time.
2. Use A/B tests for major tweaks or low-traffic pages.
3. Save multivariate for high-traffic, fine-tuning situations.

Bottom line: Clear results trump complex tests.

"The less you spend to reach a conclusion, the greater the ROI. The faster you move, the faster you can get to the next value as well, also increasing the outcome of your program." - Andrew Anderson, Head of Optimization at Malwarebytes

4. Ending Tests Too Early

Marketers often rush A/B tests, leading to bad decisions. Here's why it's a problem and how to fix it.

Why Quick Results Are Tempting (But Dangerous)

We all want fast answers. But with A/B tests, you need to slow down:

• Early data can lie: In a study of 1,000 A/A tests, over half hit 95% significance at some point. That's a lot of false positives.
• You miss the big picture: Short tests don't capture how users behave across different days and traffic sources.

How Long Should You Actually Run Tests?

It depends, but here are some rules of thumb:

What to Consider	What to Do
Minimum Time	2 weeks
Business Cycles	Cover 1-2 full cycles
Statistical Confidence	Aim for 95%+
Sample Size	Use a calculator

The Real Cost of Rushing

Ending tests too soon can hurt:

• Only 30% or less of experiments have a clear winner (Econsultancy, 2018).
• Non-winning tests can tank conversion rates by 26% on average if you implement them.

Do This Instead

To avoid the "too early" trap:

1. Decide on your sample size beforehand and stick to it.
2. Run tests for at least 4 weeks to catch all the variations in how people act.
3. Use tools like Adobe Target's Sample Size Calculator to figure out how big your sample should be.
4. Look into sequential testing for more flexibility without messing up your stats.

"Sequential testing lets you make money faster by rolling out winners early. It also helps you cut your losses on tests that probably won't produce a winner." - Georgi Georgiev, Statistician

5. Forgetting About Mobile Users

In 2024, ignoring mobile users in A/B testing is a big mistake. Here's why:

Mobile and desktop users are different beasts. Mobile users have shorter attention spans and use their devices in all sorts of situations. They also buy stuff differently.

Get this: iPhone users spend 4x more on apps than Android users. And a whopping 78% of mobile purchases happen on iPhones.

So, why run separate tests? Because mixing mobile and desktop data can mess up your results. You might miss out on key improvements and slow down your testing.

Here's a quick breakdown:

Device	What Users Do	What to Test
Mobile	Browse more, buy less	Engagement, email signups
Desktop	Longer sessions, more purchases	Direct sales

Qubit found that mobile activity influences 19% of computer revenue on average. In some industries, it's up to 24%.

To get mobile testing right:

1. Run separate tests for mobile and desktop
2. Focus on fixing mobile roadblocks
3. Use Google Analytics to track cross-device impact

Take BuzzFeed. They're always tweaking their mobile navigation to make it easier for users to find what they want.

"Mobile-first A/B testing is all about keeping mobile visitors moving through your site." - Suzanne Scacca, Freelance Writer

Quick mobile A/B testing tips:

• Keep content consistent across devices
• Make navigation easy on small screens
• Test load times on different devices
• Consider localizing for different regions

Don't forget: mobile matters. A lot.

sbb-itb-27e8333

6. Not Grouping Users Correctly

A/B testing without proper user grouping? It's like playing darts blindfolded. You might hit the bullseye, but you won't know how to do it again.

Here's the thing: your users aren't all cut from the same cloth. They have different behaviors, likes, and needs. Lumping them all together in your tests? That's a recipe for misleading results and poor decisions.

Let's break it down:

1. Why it matters

Good segmentation lets you:

• Get more accurate results
• Understand different user groups better
• Make smarter, targeted improvements

2. Common segmentation criteria

Criteria	Examples
Demographics	Age, gender, location
Behavior	New vs. returning users, purchase history
Device	Mobile, desktop, tablet
Traffic source	Organic, paid, social media

3. Real-world impact

Take Netflix. They grouped users based on what they watched to test different recommendation systems. The result? Spot-on suggestions and happier binge-watchers.

4. How to do it right

• Start with your test goals
• Pick relevant grouping criteria
• Use tools that can handle advanced segmentation
• Look at results for each group separately

"Group-targeted experiments help us understand how changes in individual usage impact related groups, but they need careful planning to avoid risks with statistical power and randomization."

5. Watch out for

• Over-targeting: Don't slice your audience too thin
• Timing issues: User behavior can change between weekdays and weekends
• Ignoring cross-device impact: Mobile activity can influence desktop revenue

7. Ignoring Seasonal Changes

A/B testing isn't a one-size-fits-all game. Seasons change, and so do your users.

Here's the deal:

• Users act differently depending on the time of year
• Holidays and events shake things up
• Your test results might be off if you're not paying attention

Let's break it down:

Seasons Matter

Season	What Users Do
Summer	More phone browsing, looking for travel stuff
Winter Holidays	Spending more, hunting for gifts
Back-to-School	Checking out school supplies

Holiday Madness

Black Friday and Cyber Monday? They're a whole different ball game. Ayat from the CRO team says:

"If you don't know the website, market, and customers well, your A/B tests could go south fast."

Why? Holiday shoppers are unique:

• They care about price and stock
• They're in a hurry
• They stick around longer
• They focus on specific items

Stay on Track

To keep your A/B tests solid:

1. Look ahead: Mark down events that could mess with your tests
2. Adjust your schedule: Sometimes, you need to test for a full season
3. Compare fairly: Match your test groups by season
4. Double-check: Run those holiday tests again during normal times

8. Reading Results Incorrectly

A/B testing isn't always straightforward. Even with a perfect setup, you can still misinterpret the results. Here's how to avoid common mistakes:

Beware of false positives

Think you've hit the jackpot? Not so fast. With a 95% confidence level, about 5% of your "wins" are actually flukes. To steer clear:

• Run tests longer
• Increase sample size
• Don't rush to conclusions

Don't overlook false negatives

Missing real improvements? It happens. Netflix's Martin Tingley explains:

"The uncomfortable truth about false positives and false negatives is that we can't make them both go away. In fact, they trade off with one another."

To catch more genuine wins:

• Boost sample size
• Extend test duration
• Consider multiple metrics

Data quality matters

Garbage in, garbage out. Here's what to do:

1. Ditch outliers

2. Ensure even traffic split

3. Run tests for at least a week

Dig deeper than averages

Averages can be misleading. Break down results by:

• User segments
• Devices
• Time periods

LinkedIn learned this the hard way. Now they use special techniques to measure group interactions in tests.

Resist early peeking

Checking results too soon? Bad idea. One team stopped a test early after seeing big metric swings. Turns out, it was just noise.

To avoid this trap:

• Set a fixed test duration
• Wait for enough data
• Use tools that adjust for multiple comparisons

Mind your metrics

Metric Type	Focus On
Primary	Main goal (e.g., conversions)
Secondary	Supporting metrics (e.g., engagement)
Guardrail	Metrics to protect (e.g., revenue)

Consider all three for a complete picture.

9. Not Repeating Tests

A/B testing isn't a one-time thing. The digital world changes fast, and what worked before might not work now.

Why retest?

• User behavior changes
• Seasons affect results
• Website updates can mess with old findings

When to retest:

1. After big changes

If you've overhauled your site or products, old test results might be useless.

2. On a schedule

Recheck important tests every 6-12 months.

3. When things look off

If your numbers drop, it's time to test again.

Take GoCardless, for example. They changed their CTA from "Watch a demo" to "Watch" and saw conversions jump 139%. But they didn't stop there. They keep testing to stay ahead.

"The day after you finish the test, it's no longer the same sample period. So, by definition, the conditions in which you ran a test before have changed." - Tim Stewart, TrsDigital

A/B testing is an ongoing process. Keep learning, keep improving.

Why Retest	What to Do
Big site changes	Rerun key tests now
Seasonal shifts	Test in different seasons
Audience changes	Test new vs. returning visitors
Performance drops	Run fresh tests

10. Skipping User Feedback

A/B testing gives you numbers. But user feedback? That's where you find out WHY those numbers matter.

Here's the thing: Many testers get so caught up in data that they forget to ask users what they think. Big mistake.

User feedback helps you:

• Get inside your users' heads
• Spot hidden problems
• Come up with fresh test ideas

Want to get useful feedback? Try these:

1. Exit surveys

Ask people why they're leaving. You might uncover issues your A/B tests missed.

2. Feedback widgets

Let users report problems or share ideas right on your site. Easy peasy.

3. User interviews

Talk to real users. Get the deep stuff about what they need and what bugs them.

4. User forums

See what people say about your product when you're not asking. It's often brutally honest.

Method	What It's Good For
Exit surveys	Finding out why users bail
Feedback widgets	Quick, specific feedback
User interviews	Deep dive into user behavior
User forums	Raw, unprompted opinions

Mixing A/B tests with user feedback can lead to some serious wins. Take Dropbox. They used feedback from HackerNews to beef up their landing page. Result? A stronger value prop and more sign-ups.

"Data alone won't give you the whole story. It's just the starting point." - Sina Fak, Conversion Advocates

Bottom line: Don't just crunch numbers. Listen to your users. They might just tell you something your data can't.

Conclusion

A/B testing is powerful, but it's easy to mess up. Here's how to keep your tests on track:

1. Set clear goals
2. Wait for statistical significance
3. Test one thing at a time
4. Let tests finish
5. Don't forget mobile users
6. Group users right
7. Watch for seasonal changes
8. Read results carefully
9. Repeat tests
10. Listen to user feedback

A/B testing isn't just about numbers. It's about learning. Every test teaches you something, win or lose.

Check out these stats:

Stat	Value
A/B test success rate	1 in 7 (14%)
Mobile web traffic (2023)	Over 60%
Potential conversion boost	Up to 1500%

These numbers show the challenges and potential of A/B testing. Don't sweat the "failed" tests. As one expert said:

"There's no such thing as a failed split test because the goal of a test is to gather data."

Keep testing, keep learning. Your next big win might be just around the corner.

Related posts

• 10 UI Patterns to A/B Test for Better UX
• Control vs Variation Groups: A/B Testing Basics
• 15-Point A/B Testing Checklist: Pre-Launch Validation
• Usability Testing & A/B Testing: Synergies for Success